Yes, the t-shirts are small sized, usually I am a medium, so of course I ordered a medium... when it arrived it didn't fit. So I asked play.com to swap it for a large and they got very confused and told me I could send my "unopened item" back and get a refund because they couldn't swap it for some reason. So I ended up selling the medium to a friend and bought a large.
The t-shirts themselves are great quality and look great once you get one that fits - if you're going to buy one get a size larger than you usually do
=]

OK The XL size is so tight I can hardly breathe in it. Normally I am a perfect fit L, but with this shirt even the XL was way too small. If it had cost more and I could be bothered I would send it back, but instead I'll just use it as a guitar string cleaning rag. Poor show Atticus!

The T-shirt itself is well made and has an attractive design, however I had to return it as the sizes are tiny. I ordered an XL which is the size I have always bought for Atticus products but the XL version of this item is more like a small or medium version of other T-shirts.